20+ Easy Desserts for a Crowd (Potluck Favorites)

Sharing is caring!

Between family get-togethers, birthday parties, school events, and church potlucks, I’ve had plenty of occasions where I needed to bring dessert for a whole bunch of people. And while I love a good homemade dessert, I don’t always have the time (or patience!) to spend hours in the kitchen making something fancy.

That’s why I love having a few easy desserts for a crowd that I can count on. Give me a good sheet cake, a big pan of brownies, or something I can throw together the night before, and I’m happy!

I’ve rounded up 24 delicious dessert recipes that are perfect for sharing, from no-bake treats and cookies to fruity desserts and old-fashioned favorites. Whether you’re feeding 10 people or 50, there’s something here to help make dessert one less thing to worry about.

Easy No-Bake Desserts for a Crowd

20230305 161444 01 1 - Amanda Seghetti

Easy No-Bake Sfoglia Cake

This one is a little different from your typical potluck dessert, and that’s exactly why I like including it. It’s a shortcut version of an Italian-style layered dessert made with saltine crackers, cream, and fruit instead of fussing with delicate pastry layers. A lovely option when you want something a little more special without spending all afternoon in the kitchen.

Light Banana Cream Pudding 07 - Amanda Seghetti

Easy Banana Cream Pudding

Banana pudding is one of those desserts that just belongs at a good Southern potluck. This lighter version uses instant banana pudding, Cool Whip, fresh bananas, and vanilla wafers. It comes together in about 10 minutes, and you can serve it in a big bowl or a disposable pan for easy cleanup.

no bake chocolate cheesecake slice - Amanda Seghetti

No Bake Chocolate Cheesecake

Chocolate lovers, this one’s for you! This creamy cheesecake has a rich chocolate filling and an Oreo crust with a little espresso flavor. It’s a great make-ahead dessert since it needs time to chill anyway. You can serve smaller slices if you’re offering several desserts at your gathering.

skor bar dessert

No-Bake Skor Bar Dessert

If you love chocolate and toffee together, you’re going to want to check this one out. This no-bake Skor bar dessert is an easy addition to a potluck dessert table, especially when you need something sweet that doesn’t require turning on the oven.

cherry cheesecake dip

Cherry Cheesecake Dip

Here’s a fun alternative to bringing another cake or pie! This cherry cheesecake dip uses just four ingredients and tastes like cheesecake without all the extra work. Set it out with graham crackers, vanilla wafers, or pretzels and let everyone help themselves. It’s especially handy for parties where people are already walking around with little plates of food.

You can find more yummy no-bake dessert recipes here!

Easy Cakes and Sheet Cakes for a Crowd

Sheet cakes are some of the most practical desserts for large groups. You can make one big cake, cut it into squares, and serve a whole bunch of people without much trouble.

peanut butter cake 4655 May 15 2018 6 - Amanda Seghetti

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Cake

Calling all peanut butter lovers! This old-fashioned sheet cake has a soft peanut butter cake base, warm peanut butter frosting, and roasted peanuts on top. It’s baked in a 9-by-13-inch pan and makes 24 servings, making it a great choice for a potluck, family reunion, or church supper.

Pumpkin Sheet Cake w Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting ready to eat - Amanda Seghetti

Pumpkin Sheet Cake with Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting

Need a dessert for a fall potluck or Thanksgiving gathering? This pumpkin sheet cake is full of warm fall flavors and topped with cinnamon cream cheese frosting. It makes about 30 servings, depending on how large you cut the pieces, so it’s a particularly good choice when you’ve got a lot of people to feed.

lemon poppy seed cake square canva - Amanda Seghetti

Lemon Poppyseed Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

If you’re looking for something a little different from the usual chocolate and vanilla desserts, this lemon poppy seed cake is worth a look. The lemon flavor and cream cheese frosting make it especially nice for spring parties, baby showers, or Easter gatherings. It’s a great option for anyone who loves a good homemade cake.

White Texas Sheet Cake 10 scaled - Amanda Seghetti

White Texas Sheet Cake Recipe

You really can’t beat a good sheet cake when you’re feeding a crowd. This white Texas sheet cake is a buttery vanilla version of the classic, made with simple pantry ingredients. It serves 24 people, and since it’s baked in a large pan, it’s easy to cut into squares and set out on a dessert table.

Brownies, Blondies, and Dessert Bars

If you’re bringing dessert somewhere, bars are hard to beat. They’re easy to portion, pack up, and serve, and you usually don’t need forks or plates.

how to make the best nanaimo bars ever square - Amanda Seghetti

Homamade Nanaimo Bars

If you’ve never had Nanaimo bars, you’re missing out on one of my favorite Canadian desserts! These rich, layered bars have a chocolatey coconut base, a creamy custard-flavored middle, and chocolate on top. They’re especially good for parties because you can make them ahead and cut them into small squares. Trust me, a little goes a long way with these!

cherry+cake+bars - Amanda Seghetti

Cherry Cake Bars

These cherry cake bars are a fun way to bring something fruity to the dessert table without making a whole pie. They’re easy to cut into individual servings, making them a good option for potlucks, family gatherings, or any party where you need a dessert that people can grab and enjoy.

Peach Crumb Bars 54 - Amanda Seghetti

Fresh Peach Crumb Bars

Fresh peaches and a sweet crumb topping? Yes, please! These peach crumb bars are a delicious way to use ripe summer peaches, especially when you’ve got a backyard cookout or family get-together coming up. Cut them into squares and you’ve got a fruity dessert that’s much easier to serve to a group than individual slices of pie.

LunchLadyBrownies 13 - Amanda Seghetti

Old-Fashioned Lunch Lady Brownies

Remember those thick, fudgy brownies from the school cafeteria? These old-fashioned lunch lady brownies bring back all those memories, complete with chocolate frosting on top. They’re made in a pan and cut into squares, which is exactly what you want when you’re feeding a bunch of hungry kids. Or adults. I’m certainly not turning down a brownie!

Oatmeal Blondies 8 - Amanda Seghetti

Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Blondies

These oatmeal blondies are packed with old-fashioned oats, chocolate chips, and plenty of buttery sweetness. They’re a nice change from traditional brownies and simple enough to make for a potluck or school event. Plus, they’re baked in one pan, so you won’t be standing around making batch after batch of cookies.

Key Lime Pie Bars 12 - Amanda Seghetti

Easy Key Lime Pie Bars

Need something sweet that isn’t chocolate? These key lime pie bars bring a bright, citrusy option to your dessert spread. They’re a fun choice for spring parties, summer cookouts, or anytime you want to balance out a table full of rich cakes and brownies. Make a dozen yummy bars!

Easy Cookies and Bite-Sized Desserts for a Crowd

Cookies and small treats are perfect for gatherings because people can take one or two without needing a plate and fork. They’re also great when you’re putting together a dessert buffet with several options.

plate of holiday cookie

Dipped Sugar Cookies

These chocolate-dipped sugar cookies are an easy way to dress up a classic cookie without a whole lot of extra work! Dip them in melted chocolate, add some festive sprinkles, and you’ve got a sweet treat that’s perfect for holiday parties, cookie exchanges, or potlucks. They’re easy to make in batches, and you can switch up the sprinkles to match just about any occasion!

0

Whipped Shortbread Cookies Recipe Best - Amanda Seghetti

Whipped Shortbread Cookies

These buttery little shortbread cookies practically melt in your mouth, and they’re surprisingly simple to make. One batch makes about 36 cookies, so they’re a great option when you need something you can make ahead for a party. They’re especially cute for Christmas cookie trays, but I certainly wouldn’t limit them to the holidays.

Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookies for a Crowd 1 - Amanda Seghetti

Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookies for a Crowd

Now THIS is what I call a recipe for a crowd! This batch makes approximately 58 cookies, with chocolate chips and crunchy toffee pieces in every bite. They’re perfect for school events, potlucks, graduation parties, or any time you need several dozen cookies without multiplying a recipe three times.

1000055464 01 1 - Amanda Seghetti

Easy 2-Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge

Two ingredients. That’s all you need for this easy peanut butter fudge! This is a great option when you need a quick homemade sweet treat without spending much time in the kitchen. Cut it into small pieces for a dessert tray, holiday party, or potluck where people might want to sample several different goodies.

Easy Fruit Desserts and Cobblers for a Crowd

If you’re feeding a group, it’s nice to have a few fruity desserts mixed in with all the chocolate and frosting. These recipes are great for cookouts, family reunions, and holiday meals.

Strawberry Slab Pie Recipe Photo F - Amanda Seghetti

Fresh Strawberry Slab Pie

Love strawberry pie but need to feed more than a handful of people? This strawberry slab pie is just the thing! It has fresh strawberries and a buttery shortbread crust, but instead of making a traditional round pie, you bake it in a larger pan. It makes 16 servings and is perfect for summer cookouts and family gatherings.

Peach Cobbler Before - Amanda Seghetti

Easy Southern Peach Cobbler

You really can’t go wrong with a good old-fashioned peach cobbler, especially here in the South! This one uses fresh or canned peaches, so you don’t have to wait until peach season to make it. Serve it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and you’ve got an easy dessert for a family reunion, church supper, or backyard cookout.

Peach Upside Down Mini Cakes 1 - Amanda Seghetti

Peach Upside Down Mini Cakes

These little peach upside-down cakes are almost too pretty to eat. Almost. Each one has sweet peaches baked right into an individual cake, making them a fun choice when you want something a little more special than a pan of brownies. They’re especially nice for summer parties, bridal showers, or smaller gatherings where you want individual desserts.

Pecan pie cobbler Recipes square featured - Amanda Seghetti

Easy Pecan Pie Cobbler

If you love pecan pie, you’re going to want to check out this cobbler! It has all that sweet, nutty goodness with a soft, cake-like filling, and it’s delicious served warm with ice cream. This would be a wonderful dessert for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or any Southern-style family gathering where nobody is counting calories.

sheet pan caramel apples recipe 14 1 - Amanda Seghetti

Easy Sheet Pan Caramel Apples

Caramel apples are delicious, but trying to eat one on a stick can be a whole mess, especially for kids! This version spreads sliced apples on a sheet pan and adds caramel and toppings so everyone can grab a few pieces. It’s a fun fall dessert for classroom parties, family gatherings, or a casual get-together where you want something a little different.

How Much Dessert Do You Need for a Crowd?

If you’re making dessert for a large group, I recommend planning for at least one serving per person. For a potluck or party where you’re offering several different desserts, smaller portions are usually a good idea so everyone can try a little of everything.

Here’s a general guide:

Number of PeopleDessert Servings to Plan For
1010–12
2020–24
3030–36
5050–60
100100–120

If you’re feeding 50 or more people, sheet cakes, brownies, cookies, and dessert bars are especially handy. They’re easy to make in larger batches, transport, and divide into individual servings.

And remember, you don’t have to make one giant dessert! A few different recipes can give everyone some variety without making extra work for yourself.

Which of these best desserts for a crowd will you try first?

Whether you’re planning a big family reunion, bringing dessert to a potluck, or just feeding a house full of hungry people, I hope you’ve found a few new favorites to try!

With everything from easy no-bake desserts to classic sheet cakes and brownies, there’s something here for just about any occasion. Now the hardest part is deciding which one to make first!

24 Easy Desserts for a Crowd
Amanda Seghetti profile
MEET AMANDA

Amanda is a mom of 4 living a mostly crunchy lifestyle north of Atlanta, GA with her husband, 2 dogs, 2 cats, a whole bunch of chickens and a cow. As a former special education teacher who also has her personal training certification — Amanda really enjoys teaching others how to do things!

When she’s not working, Amanda enjoys DIY projects, gardening, photography, hiking, and finding something new to bake.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.